Using publicly collected data to study dragonfly swarms: Part 2

dragonfly swarm banner

Whew!  Last week ended up being really busy!  But it’s time now for another summary of the dragonfly swarm data I collected this summer on my blog.  Today’s topic: distribution of dragonfly swarms and the maps!

If you read my first summary post, you know that I learned that dragonfly swarms were very widespread across the US this year.  It actually became a sort of game for me to collect reports from all the lower 48 states as the summer went on.  I was thrilled that I got reports from nearly every state.  WAY too thrilled actually.  And, it irked me to no end that I didn’t get any reports from Louisiana.  I should have.  There were swarms in every neighboring state.  There have been dragonflies recorded flying across the Gulf of Mexico.  There should have been at least one report from LA!  Alas, the summer ended with my dream of collecting the 48 states unfulfilled.  Maybe next summer…

Part of the excitement of this project for me this summer was mapping out all of the reports I collected on Google Earth.  When I inputted the swarms on the map, it was easy to see when and where massive swarm activity was occurring.  It was also easy to see the patterns in the distribution of the swarms.  And, I learned that, though a lot of the work on migratory dragonflies has been done on the east coast, the total dragonfly swarms in the midwest vastly outnumbered the eastern swarms, nearly 20 to 1!

The best way to illustrate the distribution of the swarms is to show you my maps.  Now I could put up a ton of maps and have you scroll down through the longest blog post of all time, but I think video captures the activity much better.  As you watch the video below, you’ll see a series of maps, one for each week starting with the week of 7/4/2010 and ending in mid-October.   A few things to keep in mind as you watch:

  • The maps are cumulative.  The pushpins for a week are added to all of the pushpins from the weeks previous.
  • I’ve zoomed out sufficiently to see all of the areas from which I received reports, including Belize down at the bottom right of the frame.  Every report is represented by its own pushpin on the map, but with this level of zooming you can’t see all of them.  Remember that this map represents about 640 reports!
  • The colors of the pushpins have meaning, which is explained in the video.
  • The viewer is tiny, so the pushpins are hard to see.  This is a high definition video, so I highly recommend that you push play, the click on the resolution button at the lower right of the viewer (it’s the one that says 360p) until 1060p is displayed.  Then make the video full screen by clicking the button at the very lower right.  Press the ESC key to exit full screen mode when you’re done.

On to the video!

I think these maps are fascinating and I’ve thought of a hundred different ways I can display the information they contain.  I’ll discuss what I think this all means in the third and final post in this series, but I think you can take away a few ideas from simply looking at the maps.

First, the swarming activity in the Great Lakes region was intense this summer!  I have a few hypotheses for why this might be that I’ll share next time, but it’s obvious that there was some major swarming happening in the north central US this year.  However, if you look at the colors of the pushpins, you’ll notice that the vast majority of the swarms in the midwest were static feeding swarms.  Some migratory swarms were reported in the midwest (most notably in Nebraska), but most of them were reported along coastal areas.

And speaking of coastal areas, there were reports of dragonfly swarms on both coasts!  Western areas do see both migratory and static feeding swarms.  But, take a look at the video again if you missed it: the dragonfly swarms reported in the western US were much fewer than in the eastern half of the country.  In fact, in most western states, I only received a single dragonfly swarm report.  Some of these were bizarre reports too.  The report from Colorado described thousands of dragonflies sleeping on a ranch until disturbed when the rancher returned in his truck at 10PM.  The dragonflies burst into frantic activity in the dark in what sounded a lot like the climax of Hitchcock’s The Birds.  So, swarms might occur in many different regions and I may have gotten to check off nearly every state on my US map, but it does look like swarms are more common in the midwest and east than they are in the west.

I feel obligated to caution readers about reading too much into these data though.  Consider the person who sends in a report.  This is a person who happened to see a swarm in his or her area, then felt interested enough in the event to look it up online, then spend a few to several minutes making a report.  However, my blog had hundreds of hits a day from people looking for information about dragonfly swarms while I maxed out at about 30 daily swarm reports.  This means that for every person who saw a swarm and was interested enough to look up more information about it (and I think most of these people had seen a swarm or they wouldn’t have thought to seek more info in the first place), there were about 20 others who didn’t submit reports.  The data is somewhat subjective because it is depends on the individual’s level of interest in the behavior and that’s going to vary a lot from person to person.  We don’t all love this subject as much as I do!

The data is also somewhat subjective based on some simple demographics of the states.  The state of Wyoming has a total state population less than that of the city I live in (about 544,000 people)!  It’s also the 10th biggest state in the country.  The lack of people and the space between them in Wyoming means that there is a huge potential for swarms to occur without human witnesses.  Swarming almost surely occurs in WY, but I didn’t receive any reports.  I think this may have occurred in many areas of the western US.  Note that there are several pins in my area in southern Arizona.  There are likely lots of reports in my area simply because I live here!  People in my entomology department tell me about how they saw this interesting dragonfly behavior and wonder if I know anything about it.  When I hear anything about dragonflies that suggests “swarm” to me, I question that person.  My friends are on the lookout for swarms – and they find them – because it’s something I’m deeply interested in!  Hence, lots of pushpins in my area, in spite of its western location.  As a result, I think western swarms may be much more widespread than the maps lead me to believe.  If we can find this many swarms in the Sonoran Desert, there are likely many more swarms in areas with more water.

Because I think it’s interesting, I want to finish this post up with an image of my final dragonfly swarm map and this year’s monarch migration map:

dragonfly swarm map

Dragonfly swarms

monarch map

Overnight roosting sites reported for 2010 monarch southern migration. Image from http://www.learner.org/jnorth/maps/monarch_f10_roosts.html.

I’m not going to say too much about this because I don’t know what it means, but I would like to point out a few things:

  • The distribution of dragonfly swarms is nearly identical to that of monarch roosting sites.
  • Monarchs were reported flying with dragonflies in migratory swarms in the majority of the reports I received.
  • Both sets of data were collected via submission of reports by people who chose to make reports online.

The similarities between the two data sets surprised me, so I am putting them out there for you to make your own tentative conclusions.  I intend to continue collecting data on dragonfly swarms on my blog for several more years and think pursuing the links between the dragonfly and monarch activity could be prove very interesting.

In spite of my cautions, I still think the swarming activity in the midwest this summer was something special.  I also think that swarming is much less common in the west than in the midwest and east.  Next time, I’ll share why I think these things and make some tentative conclusions based on the data I collected.  Check back soon for the final installment!

_______________

Have you seen a dragonfly swarm?

I am tracking swarms so I can learn more about this interesting behavior.  If you see one, I’d love to hear from you!  Please visit my Report a Dragonfly Swarm page to fill out the official report form.  It only takes a few minutes!

Thanks!

_______________

Want more information?

Visit my dragonfly swarm information page for my entire collection of posts about dragonfly swarms!

_______________

Unless otherwise stated, all text, images, and video are copyright © 2010 DragonflyWoman.wordpress.com

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Using publicly collected data to study dragonfly swarms: Part 2

  1. How many dragonflies do you consider a swarm? We have lots of dragonflies here on the Texas Coast and I would like to understand what is a swarm and what is just a lot of dragonflies.

    • I guess I consider a swarm a group of about 10 or more dragonflies. However, random dragonflies in your area and swarming dragonflies are going to behave completely differently. This is an essential characteristic to consider when deciding whether you’re witnessing a swarm or not. A swarm will be localized over a very specific area (almost always away from water), contain both males and females (usually), and may include more than one species. The localization of the group is very important – several individuals will make tight turns, flying in circles, rectangles, or figures 8’s in a particular area over and over and over again. It will almost look like there’s an invisible boundary to the area in which they are swarming.

      Granted, this area can be really big if the swarm is big enough. In that case, you’d want to look for the flight patterns, the mixture of sexes (might be indicated by variations in colors of swarm members), and the blend of species (often evident as a difference in size or flight behavior of species within the swarm) – and there would likely be hundreds or thousands of individuals in a swarm if you can’t easily see the boundaries of the flight area. The flight behavior is distinctive. While it superficially looks a lot like the behavior of patrolling territorial males, you wouldn’t see large groups of patrolling males peacefully flying together in a localized area, especially far from water. The point of territorial patrols is to protect a prime egg laying location from other males. A dominant male will chase off a less dominant male to ensure that he is able to secure a scarce resource (females!) for himself. In the swarms, the dragonflies tolerate the presence of lots of other individuals – and even other species – close by because they are feeding on highly abundant prey and are not competing with one another for a resource.

      Hope that helps! Let me know if you would like more clarification.

  2. As a ‘for instance’, when I went to Boyce Thompson Aroboretum in Pinal County on October 2, there were probably 100+ (conservative estimate) Mexican Amberwings at Ayer Lake (which is basically a large pond). Is that considered a swarm? They were behaving normally, patrolling and resting on plants around the lake perimeter.

    • No, I would not consider that a swarm because the behavior isn’t correct to classify it as a swarm. The flight behavior is much more important in classifying a group of dragonflies as a swam than the numbers. If the dragonflies you saw were spread out on the lake’s edge, they’re likely patrolling territories, NOT forming migratory or feeding swarms. To be considered a feeding swarm (which is likely the only swarms that amberwings would ever form), they would have to be flying together in a highly localized area away from the lake. They would be coming close enough to touch one another occasionally, but without any evidence of their chasing one another from the area. You would also likely be able to see clouds of small insects in the area where they were swarming. Because the amberwings you saw were spread out around the lake as usual, you couldn’t consider that a feeding swarm. The numbers of individuals might indicate “swarm,” but the behavior does not. Make sense?

Have something to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s