Damselfly Taxonomy Fail

People who know me in person learn one thing soon after they meet me (assuming they don’t know already): how to tell damselflies and antlions apart.  Even friends and relatives who have no interest whatsoever in insects still know how to tell these apart.  This is because the general inability of people to distinguish these two insects is one of my biggest pet peeves.  It really shouldn’t bother me – after all, the ratio of entomologists to non-entomologists in the world is probably tiny and I certainly don’t expect everyone to know more than a handful of basic facts about insects – but it bothers me nonetheless.  It bothers me so much, in fact, that people quickly learn the difference if they spend time with me.  It might have something to do with the fact that I loudly point out every instance of misidentified antlions masquerading as damselflies or dragonflies that I see.  This wouldn’t be such a big deal except that I see this mistake ALL THE TIME!  Drives me nuts, and the people who are with me when I rant about how antlions and damselflies aren’t the same thing tend to pick up on the differences really fast.  I think it’s a defensive mechanism.  If someone shopping with me preemptively points out an antlion misidentified as a damselfly, I am less likely to make a scene and embarrass them.  :)

I’m sure the vast majority of people in the world wouldn’t even notice how often antlions are mistaken for damselflies on products.  The only reason I notice is because I happen to really like damselflies and dragonflies and I actively seek products depicting them.  As an entomologist, people also give me insect gifts all the time.  Because I love odonates, I get more odonate gifts than anything else.  But not all of them actually depict dragonflies.  These are a small handful of things I’ve been given that had the word “dragonfly” somewhere on the label:

art

This was a wedding gift from one of my husband's friends.

plate

I got two of these glass plates from my mom for my birthday in 2009

 

tee

My sister gave me this shirt a few months ago. I'm thrilled that outdoor clothing maker Columbia is using insects in their designs, but...

 

towels

One of my best friends' moms gave my husband and me two of these hand towels for our wedding.

 

necklace

This was the first thing my husband gave me after we started dating. He didn't know better at the time.

Did you notice what all of these things have in common?  If you didn’t, here’s a close up of the offensive body part:

antennae

Gah!

Look at those antennae!  Big, long antennae!  Damselflies and dragonflies have short, bristly antennae.  They’re basically little hairs that stick off the front of their heads.  No adult odonates have long antennae, so as far as I’m concerned, none of the insects depicted in the items above are damselflies and are all antlions instead.  It might say “damselfly” on the label, but the people who named these products are wrong.  Wrong wrong wrong!

This pet peeve of mine is so stupid.  I don’t really care what insects are on the things people give me.  I will display nearly any insect in my home.  I am just as happy with things that have antlions on them, long, showy antennae and all, as I am with things with damselflies and dragonflies on them.  Antlions are fabulous insects worthy of being included on products for people to buy.  And I like every one of the gifts pictured in spite of the misidentification.  After all, someone I care about bought me something he or she thought I would like.  I’m darn well going to like it!

I also realize that antlions and damselflies look so similar that most people aren’t even aware that they’re two different animals.  Artists who make odonate images often don’t draw from life and assume that odonates have antennae like most other familiar insects.  It’s not a bad assumption.  Unless you’re an entomologist, there’s very little reason why you might be taught the difference between damseflies and antlions.  Still, it gets to me every time I see an antlion labeled as an odonate.  Ultimately, it all comes down to that label, the proof that the person designing the product doesn’t know what they’re putting on a t-shirt or assumes that the consumer won’t notice the difference.  And the really stupid part is that if there was no label identifying it as a dragonfly or damselfly, I wouldn’t even care! Like I said, the pet peeve is really stupid.  Wish I could get over it.  I welcome suggestions for how to do so!

Before I end my little odonates-don’t-have-long-antennae rant I just want to point out a few things.  Damselflies and antlions might look similar, but they are really nothing alike.  Odonate nymphs are aquatic while antlion larvae bury themselves in sand.  Odonates fly during the day while antlions fly at night.  Odonates can’t fold their wings flat over their backs while antlions can.  Antlions are holometabolous while damselflies are hemimetabolous, so they’re not even remotely closely related.    In fact, they are so distantly related that they have a taxonomy fail index value (as defined by Myrmecos) of 67.02.  That means that this misidentification is almost 3 times as bad as mistaking an opossum for a cat!

I imagine that all of you will now start noticing antlions misidentified as odonates.  Welcome to my world!  You will find them everywhere.  And if you ever happen to hear a loud woman in the next aisle complaining about long antennae on a damselfly shirt that she would have bought except she can’t bring herself to do it thanks to the misidentification, come say hi.  It’s probably me.  :)

_______________

Unless otherwise stated, all text, images, and video are copyright © 2011 DragonflyWoman.wordpress.com

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “Damselfly Taxonomy Fail

  1. Ohhhh boy do I know the feeling!
    Don’t worry about it being a silly pet peeve, it’s the desire for accuracy that allows there to be some accountability in the world. *Someone* needs to ensure that insects are properly identified! But maybe that’s the taxonomist in me speaking.
    I get the same way with just about any sort of insect. Butterflies and moths are always confused for each other, which is annoying. And don’t get me started on insects depicted with the wrong number of legs, or ladybugs with random placement of spots….

    • Yeah, it all bugs me to some extent (though I imagine it’s worse for you taxonomists than for us ethologists), but I tend to subject my family and friends to my ranting about inaccurate identifications only when odonates have long antennae. I have a feeling that if I didn’t focus on one problem I would become unpleasantly whiny. :) You know, what gets me more about the moths-butterflies than the constant mix-ups is the fact that LOTS of people I’ve met love love love butterflies but are terrified of moths. I consider butterflies glorified moths, so I just don’t get how you can be scared of one and not the other or vice versa…

  2. I’m with you on this, and my family and close friends are painfully aware of it too. Another thing that bugs me about a lot of these depictions is the sideways bending abdomen which is simply not possible for any odonate unless they have some serious damage.

  3. I have the same pet peeve with snails. I am not aware of any marine snail that has a planospiral shell (like Sponge Bob’s pet, Gary). Also the eye placement drives me nuts. Marine snails do not have eyes on stalks, only terrestrial snails and aquatic snails that evolved from terrestrial snails have stalked eyes. Marine snails and most aquatic snails have the eyes at the base of the tentacle. I feel your pain.

    • HAHAHAHAHA!!! My BFF went on a crazy-lady rant about the cutsie snail merchandise out there that has the eyes on the head and not on stalks. (She, of course, was referring to terrestrial snails.) It bugs me, too, but not enough for a Facebook rant. :o)

      But don’t get me started about using brand names for off-brand merchandise, especially Tupperware (oh, and watch out if they spell it “tupperwear”). “Tupperware” refers to products made by the company started by Earl Tupper, not any ol’ plastic container. Oh, and there is a difference between a Tupperware lid (not liquid or air tight) and a Tupperware seal.

      Have we lost the art of attention to detail?

      Yeah…we’re a quirky bunch here.

      • Ha ha! I would drive you nuts with my using Kleenax for all facial tissues then, and I have been known to use Tupperware to describe my Rubbermaid brand plastic storage containers because I grew up with Tupperware (the real stuff) and it has become synonymous with any plastic food storage container in my mind. Similarly, I call my Burts Bees lip balm Chapstick (my dad used the black tubed Chapstick when I was a kid) and I still find myself calling aluminum foil tin foil because my parents called it tin foil. Every now and again my husband will get really annoyed by my calling facial tissues Kleenax when we always buy the generic store brand of tissues, so you would probably get along well with him. :)

  4. Pingback: antlion, rawr! « Rebecca in the Woods

  5. I was looking up how to make a dragonfly costume for my son. I don’t know much about insects but want to make sure I get it right! Thanks for the information. Glad I stumbled across your blog.

Have something to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s